WPC n\k1ċv E[:{.N2SE0ql-zXG](LU8mYa{RCI? ԁii3G?E|ֻ|f8jߒֺ(ᘤO:nq/>ҜTm)~b֤@[ȗwI[΂͔c[2U>\$ mbm5U\3dN?C#c2S^DL2~dNJyXKa>9ș0}آR^/1zv1y#6 ؁ d}~$v>>2C`^>4+A)= ݾV3}g."WqGQ5!D#+qf--Y%k'?&Ec_Ix´s~Pdd0x3ZlD #!UN % 0(^ Ew@Q4 mHP LaserJet 4V,,,,,,0(hH  Z6Times New Roman RegularX($Wl+c DababE~v)rtyBar 3|xU !  _HH88@ X ReadingCasesCritically#XX2#   @??Prof.StephenD.SowleXXInlawschool,youhavetolearntothinkmoreanalyticallyandcriticallythanyou 8 mayhavehadtoincollege.Youneedtolearnhowtoidentifytheholdingofthecase,todistinguishholdingfromdicta,etc.,butyoualsoshouldconsiderthefollowingwhenyoureadacase:0  !Whyistheruleappliedbythecourt x,not y(orthereverseof x)?p (#(# 0  !Is xbestpossiblerule?Whatmightbebetter? (#(# 0  !Whatunderlyingpurposesorpolicygoalsareservedbytherule? (#(# 0  !Whatambiguityexistsintherule?Arethere"limitcases"wheretherule @ cant,orshouldnt,beapplied?Ifso,howshouldsuchcasesberesolved? (#(# 0  !Whatisthehistoryoftherule?(ConsiderHolmes: Itisrevoltingtohave H nobetterreasonforaruleoflawthanthatsoitwaslaiddowninthetimeofHenryIV.Itisstillmorerevoltingifthegroundsuponwhichitwaslaiddownhavevanishedlongsince,andtherulesimplypersistsfromblindimitationofthepast.) (#(# 0  !Cantherulebeappliedeasilybyfuturecourts,andcanpeopleeasily  conformtheirconducttotherule? (#(# 0  !Doestherulehaveadisparateimpactondifferentgroups(e.g.,women,  !` minorities,economicgroups)?Doestheruleenforcethelegalstatusquo,orencouragechange?Whichwouldbebetterintheparticularcase? (#(# 0  !Mightthejudgesbackgroundhavehadaneffectonthedecisionofthe %! case(e.g.,thejudgespersonalexperiences,socialclass,gender,race,age,religion,education,sexualpreference)? (#(# 0  !Isthesubjectmatterofcaseappropriateforjudicialintervention,orwould ) &# legislativeorexecutiveactionbebetter? (#(# 0  !Wouldnojudicialinterventionbebetter?Whataboutnointerventionat (-h)& all,byanygovernmentalbody?@.*'(#(#